Off-Broadway Review: “We’ll See” at the Public Theater’s Barbaralee Theater (Through Sunday, November 29, 2026)

Off-Broadway Review: “We’ll See” at the Public Theater’s Barbaralee Theater (Through Sunday, November 29, 2026)
Written and Directed by Richard Nelson
Reviewed by David Roberts
Theatre Reviews Limited

The Apple Family Waits for the Count in Richard Nelson’s Quiet, Humane “We’ll See”

The Apple family of Rhinebeck, New York, returns in Richard Nelson’s “We’ll See,” with Sally Murphy (Jane), Maryann Plunkett (Barbara), Laila Robins (Marian), and Jay O. Sanders (Richard) reprising their roles. Yvonne Woods joins this iteration as Yvonne, Richard’s partner. Retired lawyer Richard (an engaged, informed, yet haunted Jay O. Sanders) joins his three sisters in a room in Barbara and Marian’s house on the evening of the midterm elections, Tuesday, November 3, 2026. Over snacks and a shared meal, their conversation drifts from politics to retirement, illness, and the odd comforts that get a family through a bad night.

The play quietly builds toward a portrait of how America has changed under the president the gathered family members have vowed not to name. This pact of silence becomes the evening’s running joke. Marian (a loyal, energetic, and observant Laila Robins) offers a dinner at Gigi’s as the penalty for breaking the pact. Playwright Richard Nelson carefully shapes every conversation, from Richard’s Paris encounters to the arguments about voting, to the fear of what Barbara’s (an attentive and morally awake Maryann Plunkett) students are absorbing in her Advanced Placement class. The play’s title is the family’s mantra, and it lands in the final moments, when Barbara turns to the audience and, to one person and then another, says “We’ll see.” The results are not in, and the play does not pretend otherwise.

The cast makes this a family at table, and the talk flows as naturally as natural conversation does. Richard, just back from Europe, is the family’s link to the wider world, and his sisters respect his opinions even as they tease him, but Barbara is the play’s heart. The play’s central image of change is her retirement. After a classroom clash, a thrown piece of chalk, and a principal who was once her student, she hands him her own exit with a single sentence. Jane (a perceptive, passionate, and funny Sally Murphy) admits she came back to vote and didn’t. Marian has sold her house and now lives with Barbara. Each sister is a small casualty of a changed Rhinebeck and a changed country.

Yvonne (a candid and generous Yvonne Woods), an actress who has been ill, brings the play’s most direct statement about why theater matters. A fellow actor calls it “Dr. Theater”: in a room full of people, you are allowed to forget. She and Richard read a stage manager’s report about an autistic five-year-old who spoke in full sentences throughout a children’s show and went quiet when the lights came up. Barbara later says she can lose herself in the story she’s writing about Sonya. Yvonne’s story lands with particular force in a theater.

Against the noise, the sisters trade stories meant to “feel human.” Jane tells of the stained glass in the Church of the Messiah, which Mrs. Astor chose after the Titanic. Barbara and Marian recall the Underground Railroad tunnel under Livingston Street. The most telling is the advice Barbara got from Oliver Sacks about caring for their uncle Benjamin: work through the noise and violence and find something human, perhaps even something beautiful. This advice turns out to be the narrative’s reticent answer to its embedded ennui. Nelson doesn’t claim that everything will be all right, only that paying attention to each other is how people get through a bad night and through a changing socio-political climate.

Jason Ardizzone-West’s in-the-round staging suits the architecture of the Public’s Barbaralee Theater, the structure of Nelson’s narrative, and the Apple family’s gathering for a meal and conversation on election night. Susan Hilferty’s costumes accurately reflect the setting. Jennifer Tipton’s lighting finds the right level of brightness as the mood shifts and focuses effectively on significant solo moments. Scott Lehrer’s sound design and composition are essential, especially when Jane sings and plays the piano offstage. The cast speaks in natural voices without wearing body mics. There are onstage mics hanging over the set; however, there are times when an actor’s back is toward the audience making it difficult to hear the narrative clearly. The Public does offer listening devices if desired.

This latest visit with the Apple family brings a cast so at ease with one another that it is hard not to believe they are a real family. Their performances are strikingly authentic. These are people mourning something they assumed was permanent: a country, and a world, where someone would always be there to welcome them home. “The Emigrant’s Lament,” the Irish song Barbara and Jane sing at the start and again at the end, warns of the opposite: “There’ll be no one to welcome you home.” Jane’s quiet confession near the end, that she feels she has “left my country, and landed somewhere else,” says it plainly.

Richard Nelson sends us home from “We’ll See” with questions rather than answers. What do we do when the country we thought we knew no longer feels like ours? And when the news is bad, are a song, a story, a stained-glass window, or a room full of people listening to one another enough to carry us through? Barbara’s final “We’ll see,” offered to one audience member and then another, hands those questions to us. It is a quiet, humane, and deeply felt evening, and it asks us, on our way out, who will be there to welcome us home. The Apple family’s gathering runs at the Public Theater’s Barbaralee Theater through Sunday, November 29, and it is worth the trip.